The Story
I
won’t say anything else about the story, because going any further
would spoil it (more than I already have). The pace for this show is a
little quick to begin with, but it really picks up after the first half.
Still, I’ll give you some more reasons to watch (or not) below.
The High Points
Non-traditional characters
Every character is a bad ass
And that’s because the series has excellent character development
Though
we never see the main character, Yuna, at home, we do get to see the
Inubaki sisters, Karin and a little bit of Togo at home. Each character
shows a somber side, a silly side, a determined side, etc. In 12 short
episodes, we see them interact in different sub groups, we see them
laugh, cry and fight. You get a very good sense of who each character is
and what they like. It makes it all feel more even because even though
the series is her namesake, Yuki Yuna is not all this story is about.
The character design is stunning and they don’t use it in a cheesy way
Like
all magical girl fans, I love a good transformation and the heros have
it! The theme for their costume design is flowers and I thank the
Shinju-sama that
they did not think that a good enough reason to call them Flower
Fighters or some other lame title. Instead, when they were in battle,
each of the heros were simply called by their names and while they each
had their own colors, weapons, transformations and symbols, there were
no cheesy names and titles and very few names for special moves. There
was some terminology like mankai and shoge, but those are important plot
devices that are both symbolic and cleverly-named.
It hit many magical girl benchmarks, but had a fresh take on them
Faeries/Familiars
Purpose and Payment
Most
magical girls tend to be born into their powers or contract for their
powers and work to battle witches/demons/dark enemy. While Yuki Yuna is
basically the same, the difference is, not only is the power not theirs
to keep, it’s not theirs to choose. It is made quite clear that the
girls powers are from the Shinju and the Taisha facilitate that
possibility. Without the Taisha’s help/permission, the girls cannot
fight the Vertex. They are also not able to decline, because if they do,
they’ll effectively be killing people by doing nothing. Another form of
payment comes into play (and if you are really reading this review, you may have figured it out already), that some say mimicks Madoka Magica’s dark twist on the magical girl genre, but (to me) most closely resembles the dark system of payment used in xxxHolic and
similar series that deal with demons and gods. It’s also interesting
because there is no way that the general public can or will ever know
what the heroes are doing because the fighting occurs in a closed zone,
which means no shoddy disguises.
The sad moments were relatable
I love Usagi, but when she cries all of the time in Sailor Moon,
I’m ready to scream! She’s often a crybaby for no real reason and when
she does, it’s often fairly dainty with a bit of screaming thrown in.
This series included some tears that were in no way dainty and had been
building up. Dare I say it? I cried! I never cry! I did not cry when Pikachu died, I did not cry when Netero did his final move, I did not cry when all of the Sailor Senshi had
dead eyes on the ground. But when Yu-senpai found out that Itsuki
wanted to be a singer, I resisted and then I let it all out with my
girl! If you haven’t caught on by now, the second half of the series
gets pretty dark. Unlike so many other series, I find the build up and
the situation to be more touching than other dark magical girl plot
twists. This can be credited to the pacing and the tiny arcs within the
series.
Costume Design/Theme
Thank you again, Shinju-sama, for not putting them in sailor uniforms! They’re in middle school, so it would work, but I’m so happy they are not in Lolita/Dolly dresses or sailor
uniforms for battle. Again, thank you for not calling them Wilted
Warriors or something else tired. I’m sooo soo happy that there were no
name changes or ridiculous names for moves or anything like that. In
short: no cheese.
Lastly, the animation was awesome
It’s
easy to tell that the animators weren’t scared to change some things
up: people wore different clothes and hairstyles throughout, the closing
animation changed quite a few times and the battle sequences are
buttery and epic. There is even a mashup of hero costumes/mankai designs
that blended very well. There was no obvious use of CGI unlike one of
my Spring 2015 favorites KanColle.
The Low Points
We could have done with a few more episodes
While
I liked the pace for the most part, this is a series that would have
done well to have at least two more episodes. I’m not talking about more
at the end though, I’m talking about more in the middle. All of the
events that are not completely essential to the storyline helped to
build a bond with the characters and most of it was done in two
episodes. I would never say that they should remove those two in lieu of
better explaining the major plot points because I think they are
necessary, but it would have been nice to have both.
There
were a few plot points that seemed to come out of nowhere and weren’t
explained, especially in the second half. There are a few conclusions
that Togo comes to/places she goes that don’t even make sense and are
never addressed. Not to mention that I am not fully sure what the Taisha
even is because they breezed over the explanation. Even the explanation
about the Shinju-sama was a bit spotty. I’m not sure if it was lost in
translation or what, but I have no idea how the sun plays into all of
this. Someone tell me if you get it. I have my own theory but I’ll post
that elsewhere. (All of this was a bit vague for the sake on not
including spoilers…again.)
The
only guess I can make that would redeem this is that it’s explained
better in the manga/light novel series since it is a prequel that takes
place closer to the Taisha.
On that note, the ending was unsatisfying
I’ll
admit that I basically got what I wanted from the ending, but the poor
explanation of the situation made the ending completely
incomprehensible. I don’t understand what they did or how they called
that a win or what that did to change the entire system. And it’s not
like they didn’t have the runtime to do it. They just chose not to!
Again, I’m thinking it’ll make more sense when I read the prequel but I
don’t think I should have to do that to understand it.
The Verdict
High Points:
- Pace
- Character Design
- Character Development
- Originality
Low Points
- Sloppy explanations
- Needs to be longer
Rating★★★★☆
I’ll
admit that I badly want to give this series five stars, but I don’t do
half stars and I can’t excuse the holes. With that being said, I’m a
real fan of the series and I would really like to see more, even though
the story doesn’t leave much room. Still, a lot could be done with
prequels for all of the characters since three of the five had previous
ties with the Taisha. I could even see a remake of the original down the
rode like the awesome 2011 Hunter x Hunter remake.
How To Get It
You can watch the entire series on Crunchyroll for
free with ads. There are two video games in the Yuki Yuna franchise,
but only one has been released as of the publishing of this article and
both are only available in Japan. The first is a visual novel for PC, but the real gameplay is coming this February to PS Vita called Yuki Yuna wa Yusha de Aru: Memory of the Forest.
Follow @chachixo
Follow @chachixo
Well, the main reason for many of the holes and lack of explanations is that you were MEANT to read the prequel novel at the same time (they were co-serialized a chapter at a time). You weren't meant to be spoiled, though, just to have the Foreshadowing. This prevents the problems with relating to and predicting key events in Episode 8 and 10. Unfortunately, this fact is poorly advertised.
ReplyDeleteNor does it help with the ending (all you really get for the ending is some super obscure allusions during dinner in episode 7 - too subtle by far, and myself I was so floored after realizing in that episode what Yuna's hobby was and the Unfortunate Metaphor that I had to pause for several minutes, so no way I was going to pick that up).
Wow really? I hadn't read that anywhere but I assumed that the holes had something to do with the prequel stuff. I completely overlooked the overlap in release dates 😅. I wonder if those publications were translated (officially) in time for the simulcast. My guess is that they weren't but that explains a lot. I guess on one hand it's nice that the holes weren't filled as an afterthought but I don't know that I like the idea that the novels and the anime have to be read to complete the story. It would have been nice to just have that all neatly packaged in the anime. Did you find having to read and watch the material to be enjoyable or would you have preferred it to all be in one form?
DeleteWow really? I hadn't read that anywhere but I assumed that the holes had something to do with the prequel stuff. I completely overlooked the overlap in release dates 😅. I wonder if those publications were translated (officially) in time for the simulcast. My guess is that they weren't but that explains a lot. I guess on one hand it's nice that the holes weren't filled as an afterthought but I don't know that I like the idea that the novels and the anime have to be read to complete the story. It would have been nice to just have that all neatly packaged in the anime. Did you find having to read and watch the material to be enjoyable or would you have preferred it to all be in one form?
DeleteI actually still haven't read all the prequel stuff. Among other things, I don't think there are any official translations. However, a brief skim of chapter 1 immediately drops foreshadowing in your lap (what are these censored words in the hero report about how you could never dream of having to ___ your ___? why does this title character look so familiar?) Even that would have made things seem like less of a "that came from... somewhere, I guess?" moment.
DeleteReddit's /r/yuyuyu has a stickied post at the top with links to presumably-unauthorized fan translations, in any event.